When it comes to dating rumors surrounding the Glee cast, it seems like the show’s stars are only associated with each other. But in the case of Dianna Agron, it looks like she’s found a match in a costar from a different project.
Agron, 24, who plays Quinn Fabray on the Fox hit, has been spotted looking cozy with actor Alex Pettyfer, 20. The two are currently filming the Sci-fi flick I Am Number Four, based on a novel with the same title. Pettyfer also stars alongside Vanessa Hudgens in the recently completed film Beastly.
Pettyfer and Agron were out shooting hoops in L.A. Wednesday, and did some recent shopping together at 728 Alley/Kerri Parker Jewelry in Santa Monica. They even appeared to have coordinated their outfits for their outing. Agron wore a T-Shirt that said “What Part of Peace Don’t You Understand?” and Pettyfer sported a similar tee that said, “Peace, Love, and Rock and Roll.”
“Alex was making Dianna laugh so much that her face was beet red,” an onlooker at the store tells PEOPLE. “They were giddy the entire time, and before they left Alex bought Dianna a bracelet that he gave to her with a peck on the cheek.”
A rep for Agron says, “we don’t comment on our clients’ personal lives.” Pettyfer’s rep didn t immediately return calls for comment.
• Reporting by Reagan Alexander