1 of 6
A star is born! After watching her first play in New York City, the future American Idol couldn't contain her excitement. "I ran up to the stage and wanted to pose. I thought I was in it!" Sparks reflected of her 5-year-old self.
2 of 6
Santa had a cozy delivery for 6-year-old Wentz: "a Gobots sleeping bag" that he kept well into adulthood. "It traveled with me on all our first van tours before being retired," the rocker dad told PEOPLE.
3 of 6
4 of 6
JESSICA & ASHLEE SIMPSON
Before Jessica and Ashlee Simpson were stars in their own right, the close-knit sisters were channeling '80s pop star Debbie Gibson during a 1990 Christmas portrait with mom Tina and dad Joe. "Me and my sister would always sleep together in the same room when Santa came," Jessica said of their holiday tradition in Texas, adding, "And then we would fight about who gets what."
5 of 6
The 30 Rock star, then 4, loved "going to the mall" with her brother Phillip to visit Santa in Paramus, N.J. "I would always leave out a carrot for Rudolph alongside the milk and cookies for Santa on Christmas eve," Bowden told PEOPLE. "My mom always made sure to take a few bites from the carrot because I didn't want the reindeer to be left out."
6 of 6
KIM, KHLOé & KOURTNEY KARDASHIAN
Even as little girls, Kim, Khloé and Kourtney made a sisterly style statement in well-coordinated plaid ensembles for a Christmas photo from the mid-1980s. "How cute is Khloé with that curly hair of hers!" Kim wrote on her blog.