Got a secret, can you keep it?
Pretty Little Liars star Troian Bellisario and Suits‘ Patrick J. Adams are staying mum about whether they’ve gotten married, but the actor was spotted wearing what looks like a wedding band on his ring finger while supporting his fiancée at Paleyfest over the weekend.
Bellisario, 29, neither confirmed nor denied that the longtime loves have tied the knot on the red carpet Sunday at the Paley Center for Media in New York.
“We are still engaged,” she told PEOPLE.
So … there were no secret nuptials?
“I mean, I’ll never – I won’t say that,” she said, smiling.
The private pair got engaged in February 2014 after meeting while working on a play in 2009.
“It’s a blast,” Bellisario told PEOPLE in August of guest-starring with her beau on his legal drama. “It’s just always so much fun to get to play around with your partner, because you have so much in life to draw on, and you have so much trust. When he tells me that something isn’t working in a scene, I trust him to the end of the earth.”
Adams, 34, first sparked reports that they’d tied the knots when he was photographed wearing his ring at the Toronto International Film Festival in September. At Sunday night’s PLL panel, Bellisario wore only her engagement ring.
Adams went incognito in a black baseball hat and t-shirt until, when asked if there’s a character she’d like to see return to show, Bellisario gave a shout-out to his season 1 cameo: Ezra (Ian Harding)’s college bro Hardy.
“I think about Hardy a lot. I wonder where Hardy is,” she said, as Adams began waving his arms in the air from his seat in the audience.
“Come back to us,” creator I. Marlene King said as the crowd cheered.
“I’m there,” he called out.
Pretty Little Liars returns for a special episode Nov. 24 and season 6 on Jan. 12, both at 8 p.m. ET on Freeform, the new ABC Family.