Little James is the spitting image of her blue-eyed mother – especially compared to the throwback photos the actress regularly posts to social media.
The happy couple also brought their second daughter, who was born in September and whose name hasn’t been revealed, to the special Los Angeles ceremony.
Joking of his eldest, Reynolds told Extra, “When she’s 20, she can happily do whatever she wants. Thirty — I’m gonna up that to 30.”
The birthday girl is clearly the apple of her parents’ eyes: Reynolds previously told PEOPLE that “having a daughter was a dream come true for me.”
RELATED VIDEO: Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively Make First-Ever Public Appearance With Daughters
Even though the tot has melted Reynolds’ heart, his signature sense of humor comes out while talking about James. He joked on Twitter in August, “This morning, my daughter said, ‘quiche’ which means she’s smart, hungry and an a——.”
He also once wrote, “Being a father is the single greatest feeling on earth. Not including those wonderful years I spent without a child, of course.”
Last year for James’ big day, Reynolds quipped, “Happy birthday to my baby girl! Sad I lost my virginity. But thankful I have a daughter.”