Lady Gaga took home the award for best actress in a limited series or TV movie for her performance in American Horror Story: Hotel on Sunday – but it was Leonardo DiCaprio‘s reaction that might have won the whole night.
As Gaga, 29, made her way toward the stage to claim her statuette, the actor, 41, could be seen enjoying the night, smiling and laughing. The chart-topper, coming from behind, then bumped right into the back of his chair, brushing his arm aside and giving DiCaprio quite a fright.
The result? Some pretty epic side-eye that’s taking Twitter by storm.
“My favorite moment so far at the #Goldenglobes #LeonardoDiCaprio #LadyGaga,” designer Zac Posen wrote on Instagram.
Check out PEOPLE’s full Golden Globes 2016 coverage!
All Vines aside, the win was a special one for Gaga.
“It’s like one of the greatest moments of my life,” she said tearfully in acceptance speech, thanking her costars and show creator Ryan Murphy. “You’re my family forever.”
RELATED VIDEO: Leonardo DiCaprio and Tom Hardy Shine in The Revenant
DiCaprio also took home a Globe (his third) for best actor in a motion picture, drama, for The Revenant, which also won best motion picture, drama.
The 73rd annual Golden Globes, hosted by Ricky Gervais, are being presented live from Beverly Hilton Hotel in Beverly Hills, California, on NBC.