Lesley Messer
May 07, 2012 12:00 PM

The Five-Year Engagement

Emily Blunt, Jason Segel | R | 2 Stars


Here’s a conundrum: What happens when you’re rooting for the stars of a romantic comedy to break up? To be fair, the newly engaged Tom (Segel) and Violet (Blunt) are terrific-and funny-when times are good. He’s a San Francisco sous chef, she’s hoping to do her psychology postdoc at Berkeley. But when Violet instead gets a position in frigid Michigan, her career takes off and Tom is the runway. She thrives and grows selfish; he sulks and grows disturbing facial hair. The film’s energy tanks along with their romance.

It’s frustrating because when Engagement works, it’s hilarious without relying on rom-com cliches. But even a great cast, including Alison Brie as Violet’s sister Suzie and Chris Pratt as Tom’s fratty pal Alex, can’t buoy the plot. (With a daunting running time of two-plus hours, there’s only so much they can do.) By the fourth flashback of the day Tom and Violet met, I was too exhausted to care whether Engagement leads to a wedding.

The Pirates! Band of Misfits

Hugh Grant, David Tennant, Imelda Staunton| PG |


Most pirates are big on bling, but the ragtag crew of the Pirate Captain (Grant) is happy to settle for ham. (That’s appropriate, given what a vainglorious but likable twit their boss is.) While trying to finally loot enough gold to win Pirate of the Year, the Captain meets the father of evolution, Charles Darwin (Tennant), who spies something special in the pirate’s pet Polly and suggests a quick trip to a scientific conference in London. Pirates’ plot is odd, and the gags aren’t as baldly funny as the studio’s Wallace and Gromit and Chicken Run. But the Claymation is delightful, as are the actors, with Grant and Tennant heartily trying to out-dweeb each other, while Staunton turns in a fearsome Queen Victoria. As for kids, they’ll like the slapstick silliness.

You May Like