Matthew McConaughey & Josh Lucas
As if the bedroom-blue eyes weren’t enough. These two southern-born actors can both do the “howdy-ma’am” drawl and dress up their dimples with the same five o’clock shadow.
Leonardo DiCaprio & Eric Dane
The Departed star and Grey’s McSteamy share hairlines and bone structure.
Michael Vartan & Patrick Wilson
Chiseled chins and prominent foreheads lend an aura of intelligence to the dashing Alias agent and the indie actor.
Will Ferrell & Dane Cook
Stranger than fiction? There’s something uncanny in how these comics’ facial traits mimic each other.
Jason Lee & Ronnie Vannucci
Must be karma. The mustachioed My Name Is Earl actor meets his doppelgänger in the drummer for the Killers.
Michael Ealy & D.L. Hughley
Sparkling eyes plus kissable lips add up to irresistible for the Sleeper Cell and Studio 60 stars.
Matt Leinart & Brody Jenner
Manly stubble and bold eyebrows unite these brown-eyed boys—a quarterback and the son of an Olympian.
Zach Braff & Raffaello Follieri
A Scrubs doc’s been cloned! Behold the tousled bangs and lush lips of Anne Hathaway‘s businessman beau.
Check out more sexy lookalikes at People.com
A bonus round of hot double takes is now online. Log on for the extended photo gallery and more surprise matchups.